The ICJ’s Advisory Opinion Sharpens the Climate Law on State Responsibility
The International Court of Justice has clarified how international law applies to climate change. The next challenge is turning that legal framework into accountability through evidence, institutions and case-specific remedies.
Climate change presents a difficult legal question: how can responsibility be assessed when greenhouse gas emissions accumulate over time, cross borders and contribute to harm experienced in many places?
The International Court of Justice (ICJ) addressed that question in its Advisory Opinion on the Obligations of States in respect of Climate Change, issued on 23 July 2025. In September 2026, Dr. Pedi Obani discussed the opinion’s implications for legal accountability, state responsibility and enforcement challenges during the ICEED and Nigerian Institute of Advanced Legal Studies (NIALS) monthly webinar series.
The opinion clarifies that states’ climate obligations arise from multiple sources of international law, including climate treaties, customary international law and human rights law. It describes a duty to prevent significant environmental harm and explains that states must exercise due diligence, informed by the best available science and the scale of the risk. It also addresses international cooperation and states’ responsibilities to regulate private actors within their jurisdiction.
Additionally, the opinion has implications for how states formulate and implement their climate policies. The Court linked the Paris Agreement’s temperature goal to 1.5°C and stated that states have obligations concerning the preparation, communication and maintenance of nationally determined contributions (NDCs). Their climate action must reflect progression and their highest possible ambition, informed by the best available science.
These findings provide a framework for assessing whether a state’s conduct meets its international obligations. They also reinforce the connection between climate protection and human rights: climate obligations must be considered alongside states’ duties to protect the enjoyment of human rights.
The opinion does not, however, decide that a particular state is responsible for climate harm. The Court explained that responsibility must be established case by case. It also did not determine specific reparations. The available legal consequences depend on the breach and the harm involved, and a connection between the wrongful conduct and the particular injury remains important when reparation is sought.
From legal clarification to enforcement
An advisory opinion does not resolve an individual dispute between states. Its significance lies in clarifying the legal framework that may guide future decisions, claims and policy choices. Applying that framework will require careful evidence about state conduct, applicable obligations, climate impacts and, where remedies are sought, the relationship between the breach and the injury.
For Nigeria, this raises practical questions about how international obligations relate to domestic climate laws, regulations and policy commitments. The Climate Change Act 2021 provides a national framework for climate action and established the National Council on Climate Change. Consistent implementation will require climate decisions to be assessed against applicable legal duties and supported by evidence and accountable processes.
The ICEED and NIALS webinar situated climate accountability within an intersectional climate justice perspective. Assessing climate conduct and harm requires attention to the different ways impacts are experienced and to the human rights interests at stake. That context can inform legal analysis while preserving the need to prove the relevant obligations, breach and injury.
The ICJ opinion strengthens the basis for examining state climate conduct under international law. Its practical effect will depend on how states, courts, legal practitioners and institutions interpret and apply that framework in specific circumstances.
References
- International Court of Justice (ICJ). (2025). Obligations of States in respect of Climate Change, Advisory Opinion of 23 July 2025.
- National Council on Climate Change, Nigeria. Climate Change Act 2021 and the Council’s mandate.




